Zugzwang in Myanmar

By David I. Steinberg 17 February 2022

Chess is typically described as just like life: a sport by which selections must be made that can not be rescinded and that may result in both success or loss. English has no single phrase in chess or in life to explain a sure unlucky state of affairs, so we flip to German. Zugzwang in chess is the purpose at which one aspect should make a transfer, however no matter that transfer could also be, will probably be disastrous for its place and aspect, and it’ll in the end fail. That is completely different from a stalemate, the place nothing occurs, and nobody is pressured to proceed.

Since seizing energy within the 1 February 2021 coup, it’s the Myanmar navy that should act, because it claims to have the ability to control, regardless of the armed objections of broad swathes of the inhabitants of all ethnicities and religions. Even when the navy may quell overt rebellions and civil disobedience and command an finish to a lot of the quick violence in opposition to it, nevertheless unlikely, it’s in zugzwang. In a way, the navy’s coup created the circumstances for its personal final defeat and ignominy.

As in chess, the navy can’t merely declare the established order ante and that their transfer by no means happened, and ignore the plight they’ve created for themselves, nor the perils to the general inhabitants. Their declare that they acted within the state’s greatest pursuits is incredulous to a lot of the inhabitants and internationally. All sides appear to have burned their bridges behind them, and thus a retreat from their respective, a number of positions is unlikely given the solid of characters.  Energy in Myanmar has at all times been personally centered. Establishments are weak and run by people, not precedent or historical past. The highest panoply of management within the navy and within the civilian opposition Nationwide Unity Authorities (NUG) are dedicated to positions from which there appears no withdrawal. Any signal of compromise, equivalent to shared energy, as just lately recommended by the United Nations Particular Envoy on Myanmar, Ms. Noeleen Heyzer, is greeted with distinct opprobrium by all sides. It will personally shame all such leaders.

To explain the tense state of affairs as a stalemate implies protracted stasis. This isn’t a stalemate, as actuality signifies that lives are continually misplaced, financial circumstances proceed to deteriorate, no authority can deal with the COVID-19 epidemic, and worry permeates the a number of societies which are Myanmar. The downward spiral continues, whereas the official media managed by the junta presents propagandistic paeans to progress. Because the thinker Thomas Hobbes wrote in 1681, if an opinion isn’t authorised, it’s referred to as heresy, and in Myanmar at this time demeaning the navy, the state, the management, or native circumstances is heresy and topics one to arrest and imprisonment below the draconian construction that’s euphemistically referred to as judicial.

The chess world is full of detailed manuals on protection and offense, and these are rigorously studied by the intense. There are, nevertheless, no manuals on Myanmar or on the means to unravel these points. There aren’t any set guidelines, the violation of which might finish the train. The Burmese have indicated little interest in overseas negotiations, however solely in overseas help for his or her stances. However such help has restricted affect and fairly exacerbates tensions.

Ought to overseas states acknowledge the NUG presently, then diplomatic relations with the navy regime stop, and maybe embassies within the nation must be closed. If the navy’s position is acknowledged, then the West would elevate sturdy ethical and human rights objections. International states are, nevertheless, more likely to cut up: China, Japan, India, Korea, and the Affiliation of Southeast Asian Nations would probably proceed their formal ties with the federal government, the junta, whereas awaiting political adjustments promised in 2023. The West may object, and there are calls in the US to acknowledge and arm the NUG. Whereas there are guidelines in chess to which all who play should adhere, there aren’t any such stipulations in nationwide dilemmas and no handbook on continuing. It’s a morass with out maps.

And so the prognosis for the shorter time period is distinctly pessimistic, and for the long term it could take greater than a decade, or perhaps a technology, for wounds to be partly healed and new people to take over management and start dialogue. The folks can’t wait. The chess match is over; the navy has misplaced, however the NUG has not received, and the peoples proceed to endure.

David I. Steinberg is distinguished professor of Asian research emeritus, Georgetown College.

You may additionally like these tales:

Myanmar’s Present Tragedy Will Have Dire and Persevering with Penalties

Myanmar Junta Expands its Intelligence Operation

Navy Junta Directors Give up After Armed Group’s Dying Threats