Two Refugees, Both on Poland’s Border. But Worlds Apart.

KUZNICA, Poland — On the day battle broke out in Ukraine, Albagir, a 22-year-old refugee from Sudan, was mendacity on the frozen forest flooring on the gateway to Poland, attempting to remain alive.

Drones despatched by the Polish border patrol had been in search of him. So had been helicopters. It was evening, with subzero temperatures and snow in every single place. Albagir, a pre-med scholar, and a small band of African refugees had been attempting to sneak into Poland, all the way down to the previous few shriveled dates of their pockets.

“We had been shedding hope,” he stated.

That very same evening in a small city close to Odessa, Katya Maslova, 21, grabbed a suitcase and her pill, which she makes use of for her animation work, and jumped together with her household right into a burgundy Toyota Rav 4. They rushed off in a four-car convoy with eight adults and 5 kids, a part of the frantic exodus of individuals attempting to flee war-torn Ukraine.

“At that time, we didn’t know the place we had been going,” she stated.

Over the subsequent two weeks, what would occur to those two refugees crossing into the identical nation on the identical time, each about the identical age, couldn’t stand in starker distinction. Albagir was punched within the face, known as racial slurs and left within the arms of a border guard who, Albagir stated, brutally beat him and appeared to take pleasure in doing it. Katya wakes up every single day to a stocked fridge and recent bread on the desk, because of a person she calls a saint.

Their disparate experiences underscore the inequalities of Europe’s refugee disaster. They’re victims of two very completely different geopolitical occasions, however are pursuing the identical mission — escape from the ravages of battle. As Ukraine presents Europe with its biggest surge of refugees in a long time, many conflicts proceed to burn within the Center East and Africa. Relying on which battle an individual is fleeing, the welcome shall be very completely different.

From the moment they cross into Poland, Ukrainian refugees like Ms. Maslova are handled to stay piano music, bottomless bowls of borscht and, typically, a heat mattress.

And that’s only the start. They will fly totally free all throughout Europe on Hungary’s Wizz Air. In Germany, crowds line up at practice stations, waving Ukrainian flags. And all European Union nations, lots of which might hint blood ties to Ukrainians, now permit them to remain for as much as three years.

Watching all this on a TV in a secure home within the Polish countryside, the place it’s too harmful for him to even step exterior, Albagir, who requested that his final identify not be used as a result of he crossed the border illegally, stated he was nearly in a state of shock.

“Why don’t we see this caring and this love? Why?” he requested. “Are Ukrainians higher than us? I don’t know. Why?”

What Albagir skilled has been repeated numerous instances, from the Mediterranean Sea to the English Channel, as European governments have made it tough for migrants from Africa and the Center East to enter their nations — typically utilizing extreme drive to maintain them out.

His journey was difficult by the truth that he selected to enter Poland from Belarus, a Russian ally that Western nations stated manufactured an enormous refugee disaster final 12 months. After Belarus invited in tens of 1000’s of determined folks from conflict-ridden nations like Sudan, Iraq and Syria and directed them to Poland’s frontier as a approach to trigger havoc in Europe, Poland responded by harshly cracking down at that border.
Ukrainians are victims of a battle on European soil that creeps nearer by the day. The result’s a response from Europeans that’s largely loaded with compassion. That leaves refugees from extra distant wars feeling the sting of inequality and, some say, racism.

“That is the primary time we’re seeing such distinction between the therapy of various teams of refugees,” stated Camille Le Coz, a migration analyst in Brussels, who added that Europeans see Ukrainians as being “like us.”

“Whats up, I’m Janusz”

On Feb. 25, the day after Russia invaded Ukraine, Ms. Maslova was sitting shotgun in her household’s automotive, racing via Moldova, guzzling Pepsi.

As she appeared out the window, she noticed folks cheering, waving and giving them the thumbs up.

She began to cry.

“It was not the unhealthy components that broke us down, however the good components,” Ms. Maslova stated. “You’re not getting ready your self emotionally for the truth that your complete world goes to assist you.”

Driving west, they argued about the place to go. Somebody stated Latvia, one other Georgia. However Ms. Maslova had her personal plan, albeit a bit random.

She had studied animation at a university in Warsaw and her roommate’s mother and father knew a person whose father had a spare home within the Polish countryside. If this labored out, she might return to animation faculty and fulfill her dream of constructing kids’s cartoons. She satisfied her household: On to Poland.

On this identical day, Albagir was nonetheless trapped within the forest on Poland’s border with Belarus. He’s been on the run for years. As a boy, Albagir stated he watched his homeland of Darfur ripped aside by battle and noticed “all the pieces you possibly can think about.” Then he fled to Khartoum, Sudan’s capital, to review drugs. However Khartoum quickly exploded into chaos too.

So final November he stated he traveled to Moscow on a scholar visa to take programs at a non-public college, however after Russia invaded Ukraine, triggering extreme sanctions, Albagir feared that his college is likely to be ostracized. So he fled once more.

His plan was to journey from Russia to Belarus to Poland to Germany, however he stated he hadn’t identified that Poland had simply strengthened its border to repel the migrants coming from Belarus.

About 130 miles away, to the south, Ms. Maslova’s convoy lastly reached its vacation spot, a farmhouse deep within the Polish countryside.

All of a sudden, a burly man with thinning grey hair emerged from the darkness.

“Whats up, I’m Janusz,” he stated.

Janusz Poterek and his spouse, Anna, hugged them and so they all began crying. However the tears didn’t cease within the driveway.

Ms. Maslova’s household walked into the kitchen and noticed the three-course meal that their hosts had ready for them, and cried. They stepped into the toilet to a row of brand-new toothbrushes, soaps and shampoos, and cried. They noticed freshly washed sheets, towels, and blankets lined up on their beds, and cried.

Mr. Poterek, an apple farmer, had by no means helped refugees earlier than, however stated that when the battle broke out, he “couldn’t keep detached.”

“If you happen to come again, we are going to kill you.”

Just a few nights later, whereas Ms. Maslova and her household had been admiring a stack of toys that their hosts introduced for the kids, Albagir and three males he was touring with had been arrested. They’d made it throughout the Polish border undetected, however the driver they employed to get them to Germany forgot to activate his headlights and was stopped. Albagir stated Polish law enforcement officials stole their SIM playing cards and energy banks; disabled their telephones (in order that they couldn’t name for assist); and drove them again to the place they dreaded: the forest.

A minimum of 19 folks have frozen to dying in latest months attempting to get into Poland after Polish border guards pushed them again into this forest, human rights teams say.

Polish officers insisted it was not their fault.

“It’s the Belarusians’,” stated Katarzyna Zdanowicz, a Border Guard spokeswoman. “They direct these folks.”

Human rights defenders say the Polish guards are additionally responsible of abuses. A Polish authorities spokesperson declined to debate the therapy of refugees.

“Go! Go!” the Polish guards yelled at Albagir’s group, shoving them at gunpoint towards a barbed wire fence in an remoted a part of the forest, Albagir stated. The guards threw one of many males into the fence so arduous that he sliced open his hand, Albagir stated. When interviewed, he confirmed a gash mark between his fingers.

Just a few hours later, after wandering with little meals or water and no approach to navigate, they reached a Belarusian border put up and begged the guards to allow them to in.

“We wanted shelter,” Albagir stated.

However the Belarusians had different plans.

Border guards grabbed them and threw them in a frigid storage, Albagir stated. An enormous Belarusian soldier screamed racial slurs and angrily assaulted them.

“He punched us, he kicked us, he threw us down, he hit us with sticks,” Albagir stated.

He stated there was one light-skinned Kurd detained within the storage with them whom the soldier didn’t contact.

The soldier then marched them to the forest and stated: “Go Poland. If you happen to come again, we are going to kill you.”

Based on human rights teams, tens of 1000’s of refugees have been pushed forwards and backwards between Poland and Belarus, trapped in limbo, unable to enter both nation or return residence.

On March 5, Albagir and his group crossed the border into Poland for the second time inside per week, faint and practically frostbitten. They known as a quantity that they had been given in case they acquired in bother, and a Polish activist secretly took them into her residence, and warned them to not step exterior. Their expertise wouldn’t be completely devoid of acts of kindness.

Albagir plans to use for asylum in Germany, which has a popularity of being beneficiant to all refugees, and end his research. He speaks Arabic, English and a few Russian and wears gold rimmed specs and has a neat beard. He desires of turning into a physician and writing a ebook about what he simply skilled. He stated he nonetheless can’t imagine educated folks from comparatively affluent nations would deal with folks in want this fashion.

One of many males with him, named Sheikh, couldn’t communicate English, so he typed a message into his cellphone and hit play.

The cellphone’s robotic voice intoned: “All of Europe says that there are rights for each human being and we didn’t see that.”

When requested if he believed racism was a consider how they had been handled, Albagir didn’t hesitate.

“Yeah, a lot,” he stated. “Solely racism.”

“What would I prepare dinner for them?”

For Ms. Maslova’s household, the therapy simply will get higher and higher. Mr. Poterek enrolled her brother and sister in a main faculty — the Polish authorities has prolonged free schooling and well being care to Ukrainian refugees.

“It looks as if the entire nation is barely bending the principles for Ukrainians,” stated Ms. Maslova, after a physician refused to simply accept cost for a go to.

When her hosts had been requested if they’d soak up African or Center Jap refugees, Ms. Poterek stated, “Sure, however we had no alternative.”

However Ms. Poterek stated it could be “simpler” to host Ukrainians as a result of they shared a tradition. For refugees from Arab nations and Africa, she requested, “What would I prepare dinner for them?”’

Final Thursday, Mr. Poterek spoke to a good friend about discovering Ms. Maslova a job as a translator.

That very same afternoon, Albagir and the others made it to a secure home in Warsaw. As soon as once more, they had been informed to not step exterior.