An Israeli gelato shop’s journey from a Netanya kitchen to the Upper East Side

(New York Jewish Week) — When you had been searching for one thing constructive that occurred in New York for the reason that starting of COVID, head to the northwest nook of Second Avenue and 81st Avenue. 

There, you’ll spot a whimsical, pastel-green storefront with the phrases “Anita Gelato Manufacturing unit” written in neon pink letters, together with a heart-shaped brand paying homage to a sailor’s tattoo. Inside, you’ll discover an array of some 36 flavors of gelato — lots of them in over-the-top mixtures like popcorn with honey and caramel or tiramisu and hazelnut mousse.

This uptown spot is the primary continental U.S. outpost of Anita — La Mamma del Gelato, a world chain that originated in a single lady’s kitchen in Netanya, Israel in 1998. Anita Avital, 71, is a sabra (a local Israeli) with Moroccan roots, a single mom of three and grandmother of 1, who’s heralded by her household for being a perennial balabusta, the form of homemaker all the time baking truffles and pastries and making do-it-yourself jam. 

Based on Adi Avital, Anita’s elder son and a co-owner of the corporate, his mom and brother, Nir, began making conventional Italian gelato at house in 1998 with a small ice cream machine. The gelato shortly grew to become highly regarded with their neighbors. After creating base utilizing a “secret system,” they began experimenting with taste mixtures. 

Later, when Nir was serving in Israel’s military, he started promoting their creations from a cart on weekends. He began mixing Anita’s cremeschnitte (a custard and chantilly cream cake) into the gelato to create their Napoleon taste, after which experimented by including her do-it-yourself pear or walnut jam, too. Emboldened by their success, they opened their first store in Tel Aviv in 2002.

Ultimately, they expanded to 4 shops within the Tel Aviv space. After a sluggish begin, phrase unfold and Anita’s grew to become a vacation spot for ice cream-loving Israelis, who referred to as it “the very best gelato store within the metropolis” and even “the world” on TripAdvisor. They opened a manufacturing facility in 2010 in Pardes Hanna and went worldwide in 2013, opening a collection of outlets — first in Australia, adopted by Spain, Cyprus and Puerto Rico. 

Based on co-owner Alon Levi, Anita’s had been eager to open in New York for a very long time. “New York is superb,” he advised the New York Jewish Week. “Each firm desires to be in New York.” 

As an alternative of selecting a extremely touristed location, like Occasions Sq. or Battery Park, they selected an unassuming spot uptown. “We selected the neighborhood that we thought greatest suited the character of Anita, by way of ambiance and inhabitants —  the placement very a lot reminded us of the primary neighborhood the place we opened in Israel, Neve Tzedek,” Adi stated, referencing the modern Tel Aviv neighborhood. “We [also] needed to start out at a spot the place a part of the viewers is accustomed to Anita from Israel.”

The Higher East Facet is certainly house to a sizable Israeli group, in accordance with Sharon Eyny, the vice chairman of growth for the Israeli-American Council.

Because it seems, uptown turned out to be a super location for a pandemic-burdened New York Metropolis. Despite the fact that the store opened in September 2020, when the town’s streets had been largely freed from vacationers, native residents began pouring in, desirous to help a brand new neighborhood enterprise.

Consequently, from the time it opened, Anita’s has been a little bit of a phenomenon. “Of all of the dessert locations on the Higher East Facet, Anita is the one which continuously has a line out the door and wrapped across the facet,” stated Rebecca Shamsian, who lives close by. “Even when it’s the useless of winter, folks nonetheless bundle up for his or her chilly gelato.” Shamsian stated she was particularly thrilled that the gelato is licensed kosher. 

Nir Lev, an Israeli New Yorker, had by no means tried Anita’s in Israel. After his first go to, he stated he shortly grew to become an everyday. He stated he prefers tiramisu or nougat flavors; his daughter, in the meantime, normally opts for vanilla. He stated his freezer “all the time” incorporates a few of their gelato. “I’m completely happy to see companies thrive, particularly presently,” he stated, including he plans to take a look at their Israeli places subsequent time he’s within the nation.  

Help the New York Jewish Week

Our nonprofit newsroom is dependent upon readers such as you. Make a donation now to help unbiased Jewish journalism in New York.

Typical choices embrace Cookieman (chocolate and meringue), Salted Bagel (sure), Bamba (a well-liked Israeli peanut-flavored corn puff snack) in addition to a taste made with Israeli za’atar crackers. In addition they provide their very own tackle European sweet bar flavors, like Loacker and Kinder Bueno. Based on Avital, their bestsellers are pretzel chocolate (this reporter’s private favourite), vanilla and pistachio. 

Gelato is the Italian phrase for ice cream. Nevertheless, there’s a distinction between the 2: Ice cream is made with cream, milk, sugar and egg yolks, whereas gelato is made with extra milk, much less cream and no eggs, and is consequently decrease in fats. At first look, the serving cups seem small — as do the normal Lilliputian spoons — however the scoops are piled excessive and the flavors are creamy and dense. 

On the retailer, the “gelatier,” who has undergone many months of coaching in Israel, makes the normal eggless Italian-style gelato recent every day and provides the nuts, spreads, jams, and different mix-ins, that are flown in from the Anita manufacturing facility in Kfar Vitkin, Israel. 

Constructing off their success, Anita’s will probably be increasing its Higher East Facet retailer, which will probably be 3,000 sq. ft and can accommodate a 3rd show freezer. They’re within the strategy of opening an extra store in Manhattan, on Broadway and twenty sixth Avenue, and including shops in  Los Angeles, Miami and London.

Regardless of their rising recognition on a world scale, Levi nonetheless traces Anita’s success again to its roots: A kitchen in Netanya the place a single mom created sweets with and for her kids. “Her motto in life is, make your own home really feel full of pleasure and happiness,” Levi stated.