Executing Zeya Thaw Could be Myanmar’s Biggest Mistake

His story has grow to be the stuff of legend.

In mid-November 2021, 400 Myanmar navy troopers went on a mission to arrest one man in Yangon: a hip-hop star named Zeya Thaw.

Over the past 10 years, he’d grow to be a politician and shut ally of democracy chief Aung San Suu Kyi, however that was hardly the first purpose for his dramatic arrest. Except for being one of many foremost pioneers of Myanmar hip-hop, Zeya Thaw was additionally the pinnacle of the armed resistance in Yangon.

The insurgent motion has not publicly acknowledged his true position, however 4 sources with intimate data of the Yangon underground have confirmed to The Each day Beast his place as the highest commander within the nation’s largest metropolis.

The underground resistance motion fashioned after the navy overthrew the elected authorities in February 2021, and peaceable protesters realized their choices had been restricted within the face of the navy’s more and more violent assaults and techniques akin to the type witnessed in genocidal regimes.

The hip-hop star turned parliamentarian—full title, Phyo Zeya Thaw—led technique and coordinated armed efforts to root out the navy regime in Yangon. That’s the reason the junta was so hellbent on bringing him down. He was the navy’s prime “get,” however he was given the dying sentence, tortured, and executed alongside Ko Jimmy, a veteran resistance chief who was answerable for arms procurement for Yangon, and two different males within the motion. And now officers are nonetheless refusing to permit their households to gather the our bodies for correct burial.

The resistance motion is torn between eager to publicly honor Zeya Thaw’s heroism and worrying that the flip to violence would possibly offend the sensibilities of worldwide governments, who, up to now, have offered no funding or arms assist, regardless of ongoing navy assaults on civilians. Whereas the world stays targeted on President Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, the Myanmar navy’s savage crackdown has largely been forgotten exterior the area. And the initially non-violent motion has gone from beseeching the world for assist to acknowledging, sadly and cynically, that they’re on their very own. One member, who was additionally educated about Zeya Thaw’s coaching at a clandestine jungle camp, mentioned: “No apology.” Not solely did Zeya Thaw do what anybody ought to have the ability to do to defend their proper to outlive, however that, “He confirmed us the best way.”

His arrest final November was a setback to the underground motion in Yangon and his current execution a stunning act of political violence, even by the requirements of the Myanmar navy. However though he’s gone, his affect is way from diminished; if something, regardless of the junta’s greatest efforts, it’s grown, and the nationwide resistance motion—fueled largely by Myanmar’s youthful era—remains to be going sturdy.

And that could be a shock. As a result of till the 2021 coup, Zeya Thaw was an outlier—uncommon amongst native hip-hop stars for the way explicitly and publicly political he was, however much more so, when in comparison with the overwhelming majority of Myanmar’s apathetic younger era.

Acid Handout

I first moved to Myanmar in 2013 to work as a journalist and do educational analysis; it was shortly after the navy opened up the nation and launched into a path of democratization, and I’ve now spent the higher a part of a decade researching expertise, youth tradition, politics, and the rise of Myanmar hip-hop. A part of my analysis has concerned investigating how folks, particularly younger folks, outlined and engaged with politics and the political.

Sitting at a personal restaurant sales space on a moist fall afternoon in 2013, one millennial couple in Yangon had the sort of response I’d come to be taught was typical when the subject arose.

“Politics is for politicians,” they mentioned and laughed. “That’s all.” Laughing once more, they added: “We don’t know something about politics. And [we’re] not .” And so they laughed once more.

In 1988, an unprecedented nationwide rebellion challenged the navy dictatorship’s grip on energy. The navy crushed it brutally, and in an try to wipe out the opportunity of future dissent (and, thus, stop a repeat of the rebellion) doubled down on efforts to divorce politics and the political from the lives and consciousness of on a regular basis folks.

They did this in two key methods. For starters, for most of the people, the navy strove to equate politics with something that challenged their rule—protests, voting, or supporting the pro-democracy social gathering. Participation with (what they outlined as) politics was not solely forbidden but additionally extremely harmful and, subsequently, one thing to concern; in spite of everything, individuals who had been concerned had been arrested, tortured, and even killed.

Political books had been additionally banned, as was any sort of political training. In impact, the navy taught a sure degree of concern and ignorance so that individuals wouldn’t—out of concern—and couldn’t—out of ignorance—grow to be concerned. And to a big extent it labored. A major purpose younger folks repeatedly gave for why that they had no real interest in politics or something political was that they didn’t know something about it.

There was a small minority who would possibly dip their toes exterior these bounds, privately admitting some curiosity or that they felt there was extra to it than the navy’s definition and it appeared necessary. However, practically at all times, they’d ensure that to come back again to secure boundaries.

Whether or not pushed by concern, true disinterest, or a potent mixture, the navy largely succeeded in elevating a era of politically disconnected and apathetic younger folks (who additionally knew and cared little concerning the mistreatment of the nation’s varied ethnic and spiritual minorities). And regardless of the authentic motivation, this turned the accepted norm, even after elections in 2015, when Aung San Suu Kyi and her democracy social gathering gained in a landslide. One member of era Z with whom I had frequent, blunt conversations, even turned viscerally indignant at me in 2017; utilizing biting language, he defined that he didn’t care concerning the political state of affairs or ever need to deal with it.

So, it was stunning when proper after the 2021 coup, like a tidal wave, profile images throughout Myanmar Fb modified to black, then pink; black to indicate unhappiness; pink to indicate assist for the ousted democracy social gathering. It was like a collective head nod that stemmed the tide of concern.

Then an amazing variety of folks started posting political statements on Fb, as if the navy couldn’t learn their very public profiles… or as in the event that they now not cared. And it was not merely the activists or those who harbored beliefs however hardly ever spoke them aloud; it was practically everybody, right down to the least political.

Posts turned more and more brazen. Activists and politicians would signal theirs, however largely, somebody would provide you with rallying assertion or technique to battle, and the submit would unfold like wildfire— simply copied and pasted with the phrase “credit score” or “crd” on the finish, that means “credit score to the unique author,” in order that they may not be traced. There was no single chief.

My non-public conversations turned uncharacteristically uncooked, overflowing with emotions about politics, private histories, and the way they had been preventing again. Younger folks started posting images of themselves defiantly at protests. And in the event that they weren’t participating straight within the protests, they had been there signaling assist by handing out water or choosing up trash (just like the millennial couple quoted above), in order that the navy couldn’t use destruction of property as an excuse to crack down.

The exact same Technology Z child who as soon as shouted down the thought of ever caring about politics turned a fixture at protests, and when rising navy violence drove the motion underground, he turned extremely built-in within the armed resistance, smuggling weapons throughout Yangon.

With a single motion, it was as if the navy had swept away a long time of their very own painstaking efforts. To millennials who grew up in an remoted Myanmar and to Technology Z, who grew up pondering democracy and open borders had been simply actuality, the concern that they’d lose every part they’d gained, flipped a swap. Whereas earlier than the coup, there was a grudging acquiescence to the navy’s continued position in society and politics, afterwards they mentioned: no extra.

Younger folks started sharing books and data about politics and historical past. I’m in Telegram teams the place folks share Myanmar translations of every part from French thinker Albert Camus and Princeton economist Daniel Kahneman to books on native political historical past or psychological well being. One group that was about dance music would simply truth test the information after the coup.

Acid Handout

Younger individuals who knew (and cared) little about it, can and can now clarify (intimately) the nation’s political historical past, the navy’s methods of divide and conquer, to not point out the atrocities in opposition to ethnic minorities. They share articles from ethnic minority information organizations, and maybe most shockingly, many have publicly apologized for anti-Rohingya statements and sentiments (one thing that was frequent from even educated Myanmar residents pre-coup). Although younger, and incomplete, this new unity and assist throughout ethnic traces is unparalleled in trendy Myanmar.

To make certain, the violence has scared many. And till the executions, a veneer of normalcy was lastly returning to Myanmar’s largest cities.

However beneath the floor, nothing is identical.

It’s unlikely that the navy absolutely grasps the particular place Zeya Thaw occupies within the fashionable creativeness. As a result of even earlier than he was the revered resistance chief of Yangon, he was beloved as a member of Acid—the group that made hip-hop well-known in Myanmar in 2000, when their album, The Starting, exploded in recognition throughout the nation and established hip-hop as a everlasting and dominant a part of Myanmar popular culture. Acid pressured the music trade, nation, and navy to heed teenage voices and tales, at a time when youth had little clout and talking about their actual lives, worries, events or… how depressing and unhappy they had been was taboo beneath the tough censorship system. However Acid did it.

Acid Handout

Of their most well-known music, Acid rapped: “The wrestle to be free, they need us to lose.”

Hip-hop was the primary revolution Zeya Thaw helped start in Myanmar. Then got here jail-time for supporting political prisoners and protesting the navy, adopted by a profession in parliament (whereas nonetheless sometimes showing at reveals)… and now this.

To younger folks, particularly, he’s an icon. And one who felt just like the chief Myanmar wanted proper now, who revered the voices of youths as equals but additionally had the respect of the previous guard, who when folks had been fleeing Yangon amidst the intensifying crackdown, stayed and confirmed by instance how they may battle and battle successfully within the area.

His years as a political prisoner had helped form a principled willpower, and his kindness was well-known, mirrored in the truth that so many individuals referred to him as a good friend. He was a pacesetter who impressed and united and who when the navy was looking out excessive and low for him, would stroll out onto the road to get some meals in broad daylight.

Maybe it’s no shock that one younger man just lately remarked to me that he was, “the brand new Aung San,” referring to the revered independence chief—and father of Aung San Suu Kyi—who freed Myanmar from colonial rule, united the nation, and was later assassinated.

Handout

And executing Zeya Thaw at all times appeared much less prone to dampen the resistance and extra prone to pour gasoline throughout it—in different phrases, strategically talking, counter to the navy’s objectives. In some ways, although, all the endeavor—from the coup to the crackdown, has been.

The navy simply introduced a brand new slate of deliberate executions, however the resistance is at this second forming new alliances, re-organizing, and re-energized. Individuals are in mourning, their sensations numbed, however they’re additionally extraordinarily indignant.

The very first phrases one younger skilled in tech uttered flatly, after I checked in after the executions, weren’t “Hey” or “I can’t imagine he’s gone,” however, “All we want is 70 anti-aircraft missiles.” If solely somebody would promote to them.

One other mused that he didn’t know his thoughts might go to such darkish, violent locations till he heard the information of the executions.

The resistance faces an uphill battle, however for the primary time in historical past, the fashionable Myanmar navy does, too.

Nobody can predict who will win. However one legacy of this coup is already assured: the navy took a era of politically disconnected and pointedly apathetic youth and remodeled them into the very factor they had been attempting to keep away from and destroy—a era of educated political activists, organizers and fighters, who for the primary time in historical past, are united throughout ethnic traces, to topple them, as soon as and for all.

And win or lose this present spherical, the political awakenings of a whole younger era, to not point out their unprecedented unity, is a genie that the navy can not put again in any bottle.

In different phrases, the Myanmar navy has created its personal worst nightmare.