Top Chinese AirPods manufacturer follows Apple supply chain to Vietnam

The plant in Bac Giang close to Hanoi belongs to Luxshare Precision Trade Co., an electronics producer primarily based in Dongguan, China, that has provided Apple for greater than a decade. It received its begin producing small elements like connector ports and modules for audio system and chargers, and later graduated to units like AirPods and Apple Watches. It’s presently the most important producer of the wi-fi Apple earbuds on this planet, with analysts estimating it can ship round 50 million pairs of headphones this 12 months, greater than half of the worldwide complete.

Luxshare started serving Apple out of its factories in mainland China. It has manufacturing hubs in dozens of Chinese language cities, a lot of them in Jiangsu province alongside the nation’s east coast and in Guangdong within the Pearl River Delta. And as Apple has diversified its provide chain away from China, Luxshare has moved with it slightly than threat dropping its No. 1 buyer. In 2016, the corporate established a presence in Vietnam and commenced constructing the Bac Giang plant. The producer has additionally fashioned subsidiaries in India and is reportedly searching for approval to amass a former Motorola manufacturing facility in Chennai. 

Different Chinese language producers are doing the identical, establishing crops in different nations to fulfill Apple’s ongoing want for manufacturing outdoors of China. The willingness of Chinese language suppliers to comply with the tech large past the mainland’s borders gives Apple instant respite from a number of the complications of doing enterprise in China—COVID lockdowns and provide chain snarls—and lets Apple give the looks of turning away from China amid fraught relations between Washington and Beijing.

However the shift to India and Vietnam brings complications too, together with rickety infrastructure and unfamiliar working cultures. And in the long term, Apple’s continued reliance on Chinese language suppliers—even when their manufacturing takes place outdoors of China—leaves the Cupertino large susceptible to U.S. insurance policies aimed toward knee-capping China’s technological development. 

“Multinationals need to have their cake and eat it, however satisfying each the U.S. and China within the period of the Nice Decoupling shall be onerous to realize,” says Diana Choyleva, chief economist at Enodo Economics. “That is particularly the case for know-how companies because the winner of the know-how race would be the future hegemon.”

Apple’s reliance on China

Apple, like many American firms, was drawn to China many years in the past by its huge pool of low-cost labor. When co-founder Steve Jobs launched the primary technology of iPods, iPhones and iPads within the 2000s, Chinese language factories constructed them. His then-chief working officer Tim Cook dinner was a frequent customer to the nation. At this time, greater than 90% of the U.S. firm’s manufacturing takes place in China, in accordance with Counterpoint Analysis.

Linh Pham—Bloomberg/Getty Pictures

A lot of Apple’s greatest suppliers in mainland China are run by Taiwan-headquartered firms like Foxconn, Pegatron Company, and Wistron Company, which invested closely in China throughout Deng Xiaoping’s “reform and opening up” period within the late Nineteen Seventies and ‘80s. Suppliers have clustered their manufacturing services collectively for effectivity, creating huge hubs in Chinese language cities like Zhengzhou and Shenzhen. Up to now decade, mainland Chinese language-headquartered rivals like Luxshare, audio specialist GoerTek Inc., and BYD Co, an EV maker that additionally assembles iPads, have joined their ranks.

Apple hasn’t simply benefited from this Chinese language provide community: To a sure extent, it has constructed that community. The corporate cooperates intently with its favored firms, from sharing concepts to cut back prices or enhance processes to serving to fund the analysis and improvement of future merchandise, says Gene Tyndall, a provide chain knowledgeable at Atlanta-based eMATE Consulting who beforehand labored with Apple to ascertain its world manufacturing operations. Up to now, Apple has used its huge stability sheet to make joint investments with a few of its contractors, supplied provide chain financing, and shared technical data on all the things from value administration to logistics. By introducing extra competitors to its provide chain, Apple will increase its bargaining energy and drives down prices. 

Apple, Luxshare, GoerTek, BYD, Foxconn, Wistron, and Pegatron didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Changing into an Apple provider

Luxshare is without doubt one of the greatest beneficiaries of Apple’s effort to develop native producers in China. Chairwoman Grace Wang labored on the manufacturing traces of a Foxconn affiliate from 1988 to 1997 earlier than launching Luxshare along with her brother in 2004. The corporate has labored with Apple for a lot of its historical past; it even hosted chief government Tim Cook dinner on a tour of its services in Kunshan in 2017. Through the years, Wang’s fortune has grown to $11 billion, making her the world’s third-richest self-made feminine entrepreneur, in accordance with Hurun Report.

Luxshare has earned an increasing number of enterprise from Apple partly as a result of it has tightly managed its bills and funneled the financial savings into analysis and improvement. Taiwan’s Inventec initially produced AirPods however was unable to fabricate the units at a revenue, in accordance with brokerage CLSA. Luxshare began making AirPods in 2017, succeeding the place others failed with higher high quality management and by protecting prices down. (Inventec didn’t reply to a request for remark.)

In 2020, Luxshare gained a spot in Apple’s iPhone manufacturing chain after buying two meeting crops in mainland China from Taiwan’s Wistron, which on the time was lowering its presence in China and reinvesting in India.

When Luxshare went public on the Shenzhen inventory alternate in 2010, its annual working income was 1 billion yuan ($141.3 million). Gross sales have exploded since then; it generated 154 billion yuan ($21.7 billion) final 12 months. Luxshare is making an attempt to diversify its portfolio of merchandise, increasing into the manufacture of e-cigarettes and electrical autos, however of its complete 2021 gross sales, nearly three-quarters or 114.1 billion yuan ($16 billion) got here from an entity the corporate refers to solely as “Buyer 1.” Analysts protecting the corporate say Buyer 1 is Apple, although Luxshare has not mentioned so publicly. 

Luxshare’s dependence on Apple means the tech large’s shift away from China threatens the producer’s future development if it doesn’t comply with swimsuit. Shedding massive orders from the Cupertino tech large can hit onerous: Final month, GoerTek shares tumbled by 10% (the every day most) after the corporate disclosed {that a} “main abroad shopper,” believed to be Apple, had suspended some orders.

Causes for Apple to diversify

For years, Apple has confronted strain to maneuver its manufacturing away from China. President Barack Obama as soon as grilled Steve Jobs on what it could take to deliver iPhone manufacturing again to the U.S. (“These jobs aren’t coming again,” Jobs reportedly mentioned in response.) However the occasions of the final a number of years have made the corporate’s effort to cut back reliance on one nation all of the extra pressing. 

The deteriorating relationship between the U.S. and China has brought about near-constant complications for Apple. The Trump administration’s commerce warfare with Beijing led to tariffs that hiked the price of the corporate’s dwelling audio system and desktops. (Apple is now reportedly lobbying to repeal these tariffs.) Researchers have accused Apple of bowing to Chinese language calls for to censor functions within the App Retailer and on engravings on its units. Apple arrange information facilities in China to retailer person info to adjust to native regulation, a transfer that has sparked criticism from anti-surveillance campaigners and dented the corporate’s pro-privacy picture. Final 12 months, 4 members of Congress urged the corporate to reassess its enterprise practices within the nation.

Since 2020, Apple has battled COVID-19 outbreaks in China. Lockdowns in Shanghai and Kunshan earlier this 12 months compelled some suppliers to droop shipments. Final month, authorities locked down the town of Zhengzhou, gumming up a significant Foxconn iPhone manufacturing hub the place the variety of employees can swell to greater than 1 million within the run-up to the vacation season. Shortly afterwards, Apple warned that shipments of its new iPhone 14 Professional and iPhone 14 Professional Max fashions could be delayed because it tries to return Zhengzhou manufacturing ranges to regular, with one estimate placing the shortfall at 6 million telephones. 

VCG/VCG by way of Getty Pictures

To make sure, the pandemic has halted work at Apple manufacturing services outdoors China too, together with at Luxshare’s plant in Vietnam. However as a result of Apple’s provide chain is so concentrated in China, it’s felt Beijing’s strict zero-COVID coverage extra so than restrictions elsewhere. The corporate has warned of provide constraints for a few of its merchandise and withdrew its income steering for the fourth quarter. 

Cook dinner has reassured Chinese language suppliers up to now that Apple received’t shift manufacturing “for the sake of decreasing prices.” However the aggressive benefit China as soon as wielded is slipping. A report by the Reshoring Institute this 12 months estimates that the common salaries of manufacturing employees and machine operators in China are roughly double what’s paid to employees in Vietnam, who in flip earn twice as a lot as their Indian counterparts. 

‘Apple must stability all the things’

There are actually upsides to diverting manufacturing away from China, but it surely poses new challenges for Apple. First, it should management prices and keep the standard of its merchandise. Second, it should not anger Beijing an excessive amount of by abandoning a Chinese language manufacturing sector that employs thousands and thousands of its residents. 

Steering extra work to Chinese language suppliers in its new geographies is a method for Apple to protect in opposition to each dangers: firms headquartered in China are nonetheless producing Apple merchandise—and reaping the ensuing income—even when the manufacturing isn’t taking place on Chinese language soil.  

“We expect Apple nonetheless must stability all the things,” together with the political ramifications of its enterprise selections, mentioned Eddie Han, a senior analyst at Isaiah Analysis in Taipei. “Elevating the share of Chinese language suppliers is one in every of its methods.”

Like Luxshare, different Chinese language producers have adopted Apple to its new manufacturing hubs. GoerTek, environmentally-friendly packaging producer MYS Group Firm, and Lens Expertise Firm have arrange store in Vietnam, in accordance with Apple’s provider listing. Part maker Lingyi iTech and Shenzhen YUTO Packaging Expertise Firm even have services in Vietnam and India.   

When Apple started publishing its suppliers’ areas in 2013, none had services in India, and solely a handful had operations in Vietnam. On its most up-to-date provider listing, 21 Apple suppliers had operations in Vietnam and 9 had areas in India.

Apple does not disclose what share of its manufacturing is dealt with by every provider, however Counterpoint estimates the share of Apple’s world manufacturing that takes place in Vietnam will rise from 0.5% to as excessive as 1.5% this 12 months; India’s stake will enhance from 3% to 7%. China will nonetheless account for the overwhelming majority of producing.

The migration of Apple suppliers from China to Vietnam and India means the iPhone maker’s roster of producers will look largely the identical because it did earlier than, even because it diversifies geographically. “The availability chain for Apple isn’t altering,” mentioned Ivan Lam, senior analysis analyst at Counterpoint Analysis. 

The dangers of Apple’s transfer away from China

However there are nonetheless dangers. India and Vietnam supply cheaper labor, however their value benefits cease there. The nations’ poor infrastructure, weaker investor protections and courtroom techniques, and corruption add to the price of doing enterprise, in accordance with a joint report by KPMG and the Manufacturing Institute. Indian and Vietnamese employees face a language barrier with their Mandarin-speaking bosses they usually usually desire to dwell close to the factories the place they work, not like Chinese language employees, who journey nice distances for jobs at city-sized manufacturing hubs like in Zhengzhou.

And U.S. strain on Chinese language tech firms might squeeze Apple’s Chinese language suppliers no matter the place they’re. In October, Nikkei Asia reported that Apple had dropped plans so as to add China’s Yangtze Reminiscence Applied sciences Co. as a provider after the Commerce Division introduced export controls barring U.S. chip firms from supplying providers or know-how to Chinese language chip producers, irrespective of the place chip manufacturing takes place.

Exterior the gates of Luxshare’s plant in Bac Giang, a provincial capital about 30 miles north of Hanoi, the creation of business zones to help factories pumping out merchandise for firms like Apple and Samsung Electronics has triggered an explosion of financial development, remodeling the lives of Vietnamese employees. “Folks from throughout come and work at factories in Bac Giang,” mentioned one engineer on the plant. “Conventional occupations are progressively fading into oblivion.” 

Many employees at Luxshare notice that everybody appears to be carrying a smartphone now. Salaries common round $400 a month, sufficient for a complete household to dwell on.

Some Bac Giang Luxshare employees are envious of the lighter schedules at Korean and Japanese crops, the place logging 26 days every month is the norm, slightly than the 28 required by Luxshare. Chinese language firms like Luxshare have imported one other trait of their operations again dwelling—the “996” tradition of working 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., six days every week. The one distinction is employees in Vietnam begin an hour earlier and name the regime 886.