City comptroller urges Yeshiva U to accept LGBTQ pride club on campus

(New York Jewish Week) – New York Metropolis’s Comptroller despatched Yeshiva College a letter concerning the Trendy Orthodox establishment’s ongoing court docket case towards a student-led LGBTQ group on campus in an obvious try and stress the college into permitting the satisfaction membership on campus.

A letter despatched Monday by Comptroller Brad Lander to Yeshiva College President Rabbi Dr. Ari Berman states: “Because the Metropolis’s chief accountability officer, I’ve been monitoring the scenario surrounding your refusal to formally acknowledge the YU Delight Pupil Alliance, together with the appellate court docket’s current affirmance of the decrease court docket’s denial of Yeshiva’s movement to dismiss. Your college students are alleging that your present practices are discriminatory and in violation of New York Metropolis’s Human Rights Legislation.”

He continues: “I need to urge your establishment to alter course and supply a safe surroundings to your LGBTQ+ college students and employees to create a supportive area to rightfully specific their full selves.”

As comptroller, Lander, who’s Jewish, oversees accounting and financial well being of the town. “All recipients of public funding from the Metropolis should attest that they’re in compliance with Metropolis legal guidelines and statutes, together with the New York Metropolis Human Rights Legislation. Our information present that Yeshiva College has acquired some $8.8 million in Metropolis funding since 2010,” the letter says.

It goes on to state that “the College’s discriminatory actions could put future funding and related companies in danger.”

In January, three state lawmakers demanded a full accounting from YU with a purpose to decide whether or not the Trendy Orthodox flagship misrepresented itself with a purpose to qualify for greater than $230 million in public funds.

Although Yeshiva College is called a non secular establishment, it receives public funding and was chartered as a secular group so as to take action. It was because of this {that a} New York State Supreme Court docket choose dominated final June that the college should observe the New York Metropolis Human Rights Legislation and acknowledge the scholar satisfaction membership — banning the satisfaction membership from campus could be thought-about discrimination and a violation of the regulation.

The college argued that the court docket’s interference is a violation of non secular liberty, which is presently a hot-button problem within the nation’s highest court docket. The college filed an emergency keep movement to the Supreme Court docket of the USA, which was dismissed. Additionally they appealed the New York Supreme Court docket’s resolution, which was dismissed in an appellate court docket.

Though attitudes towards people who establish as queer have eased considerably in lots of Trendy Orthodox settings lately, homosexual intercourse is forbidden by practically all Orthodox interpretations of Jewish regulation.

After suspending all scholar membership actions originally of the 2022-23 faculty yr, the college introduced the “Kol Yisroel Areivim” Membership, an administration-approved membership that claimed it could signify LGBTQ college students “below conventional Orthodox auspices.”

In an announcement on the time, the Y.U. Delight Alliance stated the brand new membership was “a determined stunt by Yeshiva College to distract from the rising calls from its donors, alumni, college, policymakers, and the enterprise neighborhood, who’ve stood alongside the YU Delight Alliance, as we proceed to battle for our rights.”

In his letter, Lander advocates for student-led advocacy teams. “Up to now, student-led organizations just like the YU Delight Alliance have labored to coach members about their rights as LGBTQ+ individuals whereas additionally making a secure area for all college students,” he writes. “Yeshiva College’s personal anti-discrimination coverage is wholly undermined by the refusal to permit college students to kind this group inside their very own phrases and mission.”

Help the New York Jewish Week

Our nonprofit newsroom is dependent upon readers such as you. Make a donation now to help impartial Jewish journalism in New York.

“All recipients of public funding from the Metropolis should attest that they’re in compliance with Metropolis legal guidelines and statutes, together with the New York Metropolis Human Rights Legislation,” Lander writes. “By recognizing the YU Delight Alliance, you’ll be able to assist make sure that the rights of LGTBQ+ college students at Yeshiva College are revered, celebrated, and upheld within the Metropolis of New York.”