India and the US are Grappling with Uncomfortable Truths – The Diplomat

When India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi goes to Washington this month, he’s anticipated to be given a rapturous welcome. Modi’s itinerary will embody a state dinner with U.S. President Joe Biden, a historic second handle to the U.S. Congress, and a now customary sold-out viewers with the Indian diaspora.

Given India’s vociferously impartial stance on the Ukraine warfare, it’s secure to say that Washington goes out of its solution to make Modi really feel snug. The U.S. hopes that in doing so, it will ultimately be capable of pull India away from Russia and in addition persuade it to offer help to American troops throughout a possible battle over Taiwan.

Maybe simply as importantly, India’s protection sector is a singularly profitable marketplace for American producers. Within the run-up to Modi’s go to, each U.S. Protection Secretary Lloyd Austin and Nationwide Safety Adviser Jake Sullivan went on separate journeys to India to underline that precedence. And extra lately, India was reported to have signed a deal to purchase greater than two dozen American drones.

To make sure, it is a largely transactional interplay. India wants U.S. help to shore up its thinly stretched army belongings and construct capability. Early this yr, the Indian Air Pressure instructed Parliament that its air squadrons are working at about three-fourths of the sanctioned capability. Final yr, India commissioned its first indigenously constructed plane service, however owing to painful bureaucratic delays, it entered service nearly out of date.

In that context, India hopes that joint growth with the U.S. will assist drag its protection business to extra up to date instances. Days earlier than Modi’s journey, experiences mentioned {that a} deal was anticipated to permit the joint manufacturing of engines for Indian fighter plane. Deeper cooperation and capability constructing are additionally desperately wanted on the intelligence entrance, particularly as India grapples with sudden adjustments on the border with China.

Having fun with this text? Click on right here to subscribe for full entry. Simply $5 a month.

But, between all of this widespread floor is a big moat.

For one, as a lot as India needs entry to superior protection know-how from the U.S., it additionally jealously guards its strategic autonomy, and New Delhi is as cautious of dependence on the U.S. as it’s on anyone else.

Within the wake of the Ukraine invasion, many analysts argued that India’s sustained protection ties with Russia had been necessitated by the truth that a big a part of its present arsenal trusted Russian spare components and provides. However sustained protection ties with Russia are additionally a solution to preempt dependence on the U.S.

Over the past a number of years, India has tried to diversify its army provides by inducting weaponry from companions resembling France and Israel quite than pivoting to the U.S. And paradoxically, the scope of ties with Russia has solely expanded after the Ukraine invasion — commerce having skyrocketed due to large will increase in imports of oil and coal from Russia.

In the meantime, as a lot as China would possibly show to be a typical drawback for India and the U.S., it is usually an indication of a number of variations. In case you had been to ask Modi and Biden why China is a risk, they’re prone to agree on nearly nothing. India is extra anxious in regards to the land-based risk posed by the Chinese language military within the Himalayas. However for the U.S., that’s a marginal problem versus China’s maritime actions within the South China Sea, the Indian Ocean and the Taiwan Strait.

Washington additionally sees China as a strategic risk to a U.S.-led world order. However whereas India would possibly favor American hegemony to Chinese language hegemony, it additionally sees China’s rise as a chance to determine a extra multipolar order, given the vast disparity in energy between Beijing and Washington. Below Modi, India has additionally taken stances much like China’s on a lot of world governance debates, together with norms of democracy, freedom of faith, human rights, knowledge privateness and localization, cybersecurity and so forth.

America’s ties to India have lengthy been subjected to nice expectations — waxing and waning primarily based on India’s coverage responses to numerous world occasions. When Modi goes to Washington this month, he’ll reckon with decidedly the best expectations but, on the again of a number of epoch-shaping challenges in Ukraine and Taiwan. However for now, it appears to be like like each India and the U.S. need to sweep these issues below the carpet.