Two Superpowers Walk Into a Garden

This transcript was created utilizing speech recognition software program. Whereas it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it could comprise errors. Please overview the episode audio earlier than quoting from this transcript and e mail transcripts@nytimes.com with any questions.

From “The New York Occasions,” I’m Sabrina Tavernise, and that is “The Day by day.”

This week, one of the extremely anticipated diplomatic occasions of the yr came about in a mansion exterior San Francisco —

— the place President Biden and Xi Jinping of China met to restore their nations relations.

— which had sunk to one of many lowest factors since they have been established in 1972.

Immediately, my colleague, Edward Wong, on the hassle to convey the connection again from the brink.

It’s Friday, November 17.

So Ed, we’ve been speaking to you all through this yr concerning the world’s most essential relationship, and that’s the relationship between the USA and China.

And this week, there was a breakthrough of kinds. President Biden and Chinese language chief Xi Jinping met on Wednesday in the USA. So assist us perceive what was at stake right here.

Effectively, Sabrina, that is the primary time that Xi Jinping has come to the USA since 2017, and these two leaders are the heads of countries which might be the preeminent financial and army powers on this planet proper now. However as of late, what we’re seeing is that the army dimension of the connection is beginning to overshadow the financial ties. The US is consistently telling us concerning the fast enlargement of China’s army, its progress. And on Beijing’s aspect, they see the US as an influence that wishes to have unfettered army entry all through the Asia-Pacific.

So what you’re saying is that they’re maybe slowly however steadily turning into army rivals.

That’s proper. And what we’re listening to from President Biden and his aides is that the US and China really want to have high-level diplomacy to determine what guardrails to placed on the connection, in order that they don’t find yourself in an armed battle.

OK, in order that’s the worldwide safety stakes of this assembly, that are fairly substantial.

That’s proper. It’s a really fraught backdrop. Many nations on this planet see the connection between the US and China because the one on this planet that would have an effect on the economies and even the army growth of different nations. And lots of people who’ve been watching the connection carefully say it had reached an all-time low.

We, after all, have talked loads on the present, you and I, Ed, about China’s relationship with the US and the way it has soured. So if we have been to return and remind individuals what all has occurred to steer as much as this second, the place would you start? What’s the second you’d begin to assist us perceive that?

Effectively, issues have been already very dangerous earlier than Biden got here into the workplace, as a result of the relations had entered a downward spiral throughout the Trump period. After which, when Biden got here in, Chinese language officers actually thought issues would possibly enhance, however Biden continued to take a confrontational strategy in direction of China. After which, there have been issues exterior his management that actually made issues worse.

So one of many greatest flashpoints that came about in US-China relations was when Nancy Pelosi, the Home Speaker, determined to go to Taiwan in August of 2022. And the Home Speaker, one of many highest-ranking officers within the US, visiting Taiwan is an enormous deal — one thing that President Biden had stated he didn’t need to occur.

And remind me, Ed, why that was such an inflammatory factor.

Effectively, China sees Taiwan as part of China, not as an unbiased authorities. And so it doesn’t need different nations to have diplomatic relations with Taiwan. So then, China took very aggressive army actions to retaliate in opposition to that.

It fired off missiles across the Taiwan Strait, and it additionally went additional. It broke off high-level dialogues with the US, together with army conversations that have been going down between the highest commanders of each nations.

And what does it imply, precisely, Ed, to interrupt off army dialogue?

Effectively, when you’ve got two nations which have militaries as massive as China and the US, and when these nations are rivals, you actually need to have robust strains of communication between the army leaders. The reason being as a result of the militaries of those two nations would possibly brush up in opposition to one another in a number of totally different settings around the globe. And so that you need leaders to have the ability to discuss to one another to determine what’s occurring if a disaster begins to erupt, and that would then find yourself stopping a bigger armed battle.

So in different phrases, they’re attempting to stop the form of misunderstanding that may result in battle, which may occur when there’s most suspicion and minimal communication between two nations. Proper?

That’s proper. So this is essential, and it turned a longtime follow throughout the Chilly Conflict. In that period, America and the Soviet Union had these very shut strains of communication among the many militaries to be able to stop nuclear conflict. The 2 militaries have been working throughout the globe, they usually wished to be sure that there wasn’t a disaster that would develop, just like the Cuban Missile Disaster, for instance, that would result in a nuclear confrontation.

Proper. As a result of our relationship with the Soviet Union was basically certainly one of two army adversaries, proper? However we managed to keep away from nuclear battle by way of these again channels — what you’re calling military-to-military communication.

That’s proper. So I believe individuals perceive that this is a vital basis to put amongst rivals of this dimension. And US officers inform me that this is likely one of the most essential issues they will presumably do with China. They’ve been saying that military-to-military ties are pretty weak between the US and China, they usually’re very involved about this.

And what makes the American officers so anxious is that in recent times, the Chinese language and the American militaries have been coming to nearer and nearer contact all throughout Asia. This has been occurring, for instance, within the South China Sea, as Chinese language vessels and plane come into nearer contact with American Naval ships and American jets there. And US officers inform me that as these militaries come into nearer contact with one another, they really want the leaders of the militaries to be speaking rapidly to one another to be sure that a disaster doesn’t erupt.

So after China severs these military-to-military communications, what occurs then?

Effectively, inside a few months, President Biden declares a really formidable coverage in direction of China, which is a restriction on exports of essentially the most superior microchips to China. And China sees this as an enormous provocation. They see this because the US attempting to restrict China’s financial progress and to essentially maintain the nation down.

So that is one other huge bump within the relationship. Is there some extent the place the 2 sides attempt to reset form of have a cooling-off interval?

Effectively, President Biden and President Xi have an essential assembly that November in Bali.

And so they’re assembly on the sidelines of the G20 summit.

These two males had by no means met earlier than in individual because the leaders of their nations.

So the entire function of this assembly was for every chief to inform the opposite one which there wanted to be some basis of stability within the relationship. They wished to have the ability to climate sure storms like what occurred with Nancy Pelosi when she went to Taiwan. They thought that this might be the beginning of an effort to essentially convey relations in 2023 again to a better stage.

However then, as we all know, after all, that will get examined fairly rapidly with that unusual Chinese language spy balloon floating over Montana in February. You and I did an episode about that. It was form of unclear precisely what it was, whether or not the Chinese language had wished to ship it. However at any fee, the connection remains to be on the rocks.

Proper. And in the mean time, Sabrina, US officers have been attempting to determine whether or not Xi was the one who had given the inexperienced mild for this balloon to go over the US, and that it simply occurred that the People found it. However the US intelligence businesses discovered that the balloon had drifted off track.

After which, additionally they came upon that Xi didn’t know concerning the balloon, that it was a program below the PLA, the Chinese language army, and that Xi solely came upon about it after it’d come over the US, and that Xi even acquired livid at his generals for what occurred.

Proper. I imply, I bear in mind ending that episode pondering, it was fairly loopy that this large relationship is blown off track by this little balloon, proper? And on the time, you stated each nations actually badly wished to get to the purpose the place incidents like that didn’t paralyze them. However it appeared unlikely on the time. That’s how we ended that episode. So what will get these leaders again to the desk? What occurs?

So the US and China resolve to have interaction on this intense diplomatic scramble to essentially attempt to get high-level talks again on observe. And the US begins sending a sequence of senior Biden aides to China.

In June, I went with Blinken when he made his go to, lastly, to China. It was his first go to as Secretary of State. After which, another Cupboard secretaries adopted.

After which —

Xi Jinping even determined to fulfill with Chuck Schumer, the senior Democrat within the Senate —

— and Gavin Newsom, the Governor of California. And I believe what that actually confirmed was that Xi himself actually wished to get the diplomacy on a steady footing.

And whereas all this was happening, individuals in each capitals have been questioning whether or not this meant that Xi would resolve to return to the USA sooner or later this fall and meet with Biden.

I imply, I bear in mind you and I have been speaking about this, proper? And it was form of unclear whether or not he would. The jury was out for fairly some time.

Yeah, it wasn’t fairly sure. Only a few weeks in the past, US officers have been telling me that the possibilities are most likely 70/30 that Xi would come. And right here in Washington, among the many diplomatic press corps and the White Home reporters have been all attempting to resolve whether or not to pack our baggage to go to San Francisco for a gathering. After which, we lastly acquired phrase final week that Xi was on his method. And this was the assembly that folks had been ready for all all year long.

We’ll be proper again.

So what really occurs at this much-anticipated assembly on Wednesday? Carry us into the room.

Effectively, Sabrina, Xi Jinping flies into San Francisco, and he and his convoy go south of town to an enormous property close to the coast. That is the Filoli Property, which was based by a gold baron a century in the past. It’s lush. There’s wonderful timber far and wide. And Xi pulls up —

— in his Chinese language-made red-flag limousine on the door of the manor.

And Biden then greets Xi proper there on the pink carpet. They shake fingers, after which they stroll collectively contained in the property. And at 11:30 or so —

The 2 ship opening remarks.

Biden tells Xi that he’s there to be sure that the 2 leaders and the 2 nations have clear strains of communication, that they actually perceive one another’s intentions.

And Xi tells Biden and the general public —

— that planet Earth is sufficiently big for 2 superpowers.

That the 2 can coexist and cooperate, they usually don’t should be rivals.

And I believe what’s attention-grabbing, Sabrina, whenever you take heed to these two units of remarks is that Xi doesn’t even need to body the US-China relationship as a contest or as a rivalry, whereas Biden could be very express that they’re engaged in competitors. And in a method, the 2 leaders are speaking previous one another, even of their public remarks.

Proper. Biden really appears to have the extra hawkish place in these conferences, when you’re listening to the general public statements. So what do we all know then about what occurs as soon as they really get into the room?

Effectively, Sabrina, each Biden and Xi talked about among the huge long-running points between the 2 nations like Taiwan. However either side additionally affirmed that there have been areas of cooperation that they might transfer ahead on. One among them was local weather change.

Additionally they stated that China would attempt to restrict the export of chemical compounds which might be used to make fentanyl. However I believe what’s extra essential is that the 2 leaders understand their governments wanted to ascertain guidelines of the rivalry and that they couldn’t let issues spin uncontrolled.

OK, so guidelines of this new rivalry we’ve been speaking about — what sorts of guidelines? What did they really resolve?

Effectively, I believe one of many outcomes that everybody hoped for was that the 2 nations would reestablish high-level talks between their army commanders. US officers have been working onerous to attempt to get that re-established, and out of this assembly, each leaders agreed that ought to occur.

In order that communication channel is open once more. What else was on the desk on the safety entrance? What different guardrails did they talk about?

Effectively, one factor that has stunned US officers is that Chinese language officers appear extra prepared to enter into talks over arms management. Now, China had wished to keep away from doing this for a very long time. And I believe that at this assembly, there have been extra encouraging indicators that Chinese language officers have been prepared to do that.

And at arms management — clearly, famously, the USA did loads of it with the Soviets. Why is China asking for it, precisely?

Effectively, China sees the US beginning to construct up its army alliances across the Asia-Pacific. And it sees the US attempting to deploy extra ballistic missiles all around the Asia-Pacific area. And the apparent function for that may be to intention these missiles at China within the occasion of conflict.

So the US is sending Tomahawk missiles to Japan, for instance, because of strengthening its alliances with Tokyo. And so China is worried about this. It doesn’t need extra deployment of those missiles throughout it. And so it’s prepared to at the very least begin partaking the US in attainable arms management talks.

And the US can also be very involved. US officers have been watching China’s buildup of its nuclear arsenal for some months now. Proper now, it’s the third-ranking nation when it comes to variety of nuclear warheads — nonetheless far beneath US and Russia, however it may rapidly speed up the expansion of its arsenal.

However it feels like, from the Chinese language perspective, the US is, actually, the one with the damaging conduct. The Chinese language are principally saying, hey, guys, you’re telling us to placed on this seat belt, observe the principles of the highway. However you guys are those which might be driving the automobile 90 miles an hour.

China has lengthy felt that method, and it believes that US forces are the army aggressors within the Asia-Pacific. They assume that the US Navy is pushing the boundaries of the place it operates and that it’s not respecting the boundaries that China is attempting to set within the area there.

It strikes me that Xi, in loads of methods, form of appears just like the peacemaker right here. I imply, he’s presenting himself as above the fray and saying, hey, we actually need to put the brakes on this. We don’t see this relationship as a confrontation.

Effectively, that is one thing that China has been attempting to place ahead on this planet for some months now. It needs China and Xi to appear to be these are the adults within the room. Xi needs to make it appear to be he’s the one who’s attempting to maintain every thing on a steady footing with the USA.

He needs it to make it appear to be the US is the aggressor within the relationship. And it’s in line with the best way they’ve approached another conflicts around the globe. China has typically referred to as for peace talks in Ukraine. It’s now calling for a ceasefire within the Israel-Gaza conflict. And so it likes to current this picture of itself as the principle diplomatic power that’s countering better aggression by the US.

So how does this assembly wrap up? How does it finish?

Effectively, the 2 sides talked with one another for 2 hours at that lengthy desk within the manor, after which Biden and Xi went off to have a two-hour lunch assembly in a a lot smaller setting. And so they ate rooster in addition to rice pilaf and another California specialties.

Doesn’t appear very elegant for a dinner for the Chinese language chief, however what are you going to do?

Proper.

OK. So stepping again and taking a look at this assembly with a little bit little bit of hindsight, Ed, how ought to I perceive what occurred right here? I imply, we began off this dialog speaking about how the US and China are actually transitioning to a brand new form of relationship, this type of army rivalry. The place are we within the arc of that transition, and the way will we perceive this assembly in that context?

Effectively, Sabrina, I believe we’re someplace possibly in the midst of that arc. The dynamics began a couple of years in the past, and it’s accelerating now. China’s army buildup is horrifying many US officers, and that gained’t finish anytime quickly.

And the US intends to keep up its army dominance of the Asia-Pacific. These two issues are incompatible. And I believe what we’ll see is additional disaster factors within the highway forward. Once they discuss reaching settlement on sure small issues like fentanyl, that’s simply to attempt to keep a sure stage of stability within the relationship.

However on the large points like Taiwan, like which army will get dominance of the area, these are large questions that each nations haven’t tackled but in any passable method. And I believe that it’ll be onerous for each of them to handle these points in a diplomatic setting.

So that you’re saying, in loads of essential methods, this didn’t really decrease the temperature that a lot. Maybe that is extra like a brief pause in what’s prone to be an total declining relationship.

Proper. I wouldn’t even name it a pause, Sabrina. I might say that I believe either side most likely accepted the course the connection goes at this level, however that they understand they should keep communications. And that was the bar that Biden and his aides set for us once they briefed us on these talks earlier than they started. They set a really low bar, saying all they wished to do was keep some stage of communication.

However Ed, I suppose, excited about this assembly and your telling me about it, you recognize, what I might say is at the very least, they now have some seatbelts. Proper? It’s doubtlessly not fairly as harmful. Do we’ve got a way of how Xi is basically seeing this?

Effectively, we all know that Xi has made loads of public remarks during which he’s actually pointed to aggressive strikes by the US. This yr, for instance, he stated for the primary time in a setting that the US is attempting to comprise China. They see the US as attempting to implant its guidelines and its establishments around the globe, whether or not it’s by way of the commerce offers and negotiates, or whether or not it’s by way of American dominance within the United Nations or the World Financial institution, for instance, and that every one of those guidelines are set to attempt to restrict the expansion of different superpowers. So when the US officers discuss what they name a rules-based worldwide order, Chinese language officers, Russian officers, and plenty of others see this as US makes an attempt to maintain different nations down.

So Chinese language officers are basically saying, OK, you need guidelines, however whose guidelines? They’re successfully your guidelines. We need to set our personal.

Precisely, Sabrina. I believe what we’re going to see arising within the months forward is that China will more and more push to set these guidelines, and that that is one other space of confrontation between the 2 nations.

Ed, thanks.

Thanks, Sabrina.

We’ll be proper again.

Right here’s what else it’s best to know right this moment. On Thursday, a day after it took management of Shifa Hospital, the most important hospital within the Gaza Strip, the Israeli army was nonetheless looking the positioning for proof to show its declare that the hospital hid a secret Hamas base. The declare that Hamas operated from inside the sprawling hospital advanced has been central to Israel’s protection of its army marketing campaign in Gaza, which is now stated to have killed greater than 11,000 individuals.

The army has but to current documentation of a community of tunnels, however Israel launched a number of movies to bolster its case — one on Thursday of what it stated was a tunnel that was utilized by Hamas. Nonetheless, it was unclear from the video what function the passageway served or how far it prolonged. One other video confirmed a few dozen weapons, a grenade, protecting vests, and army uniforms it stated its troopers had discovered inside an MRI unit on the hospital.

“The Occasions” couldn’t confirm the provenance of the weapons. A Hamas spokesman on Thursday accused Israel of planting them. America, for its half, stated on Thursday that it believed that Hamas had been utilizing the advanced as a base.

And a jury convicted David DePape of federal crimes for breaking into the house of Consultant Nancy Pelosi in October of 2022 and bludgeoning her husband, Paul, with a hammer. In accordance with testimony at trial, DePape turned obsessive about right-wing conspiracy theories and embraced the dehumanizing language about Nancy Pelosi that conservative pundits and politicians have used for years. The assault raised fears about political violence forward of final yr’s midterm elections. DePape faces the opportunity of a long time in jail.

Immediately’s episode was produced by Shannon Lin, Luke Vander Ploeg, and Sydney Harper. It was edited by MJ Davis Lin with assist from Brendan Klinkenberg, comprises unique music by Dan Powell and Marion Lozano, and was engineered by Alyssa Moxley. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsverk of Wonderly.

That’s it for “The Day by day.” I’m Sabrina Tavernise. See you on Monday.