How Olivia Chow should handle property tax increase

Olivia Chow broke obstacles final week when she was elected Toronto’s subsequent mayor. After she formally takes workplace on July 12, she’ll be the primary girl to realize the title since amalgamation. She’ll even be the primary racialized individual to carry the job since, nicely, ever.

And whereas not as monumental — besides possibly to the nerdiest of municipal coverage wonks — it’s price noting one other barrier damaged: she’ll be the primary Toronto mayor in current historical past to win on a platform of elevating property taxes.

Chow’s victory is a knockout punch to the standard knowledge that claims you possibly can’t win in case you don’t promise to maintain will increase to Toronto’s residential property taxes — that are among the many lowest within the GTA — at or under the speed of inflation.

It additionally provides her actual flexibility to deal with Toronto’s many challenges. Former mayor John Tory, elected and re-elected twice whereas making the inflationary property tax promise, ended up attempting to run the town whereas carrying the fiscal equal of handcuffs. Tory’s inflationary property tax will increase didn’t even present sufficient funds to maintain up with inhabitants development and proved to be a recipe for civic decline.

Chow has an actual alternative to chart a greater path, nevertheless it’s one rife with political hazard. Toronto’s conservative institution is itching to solid Chow as a tax-and-spend politician who retains elevating property taxes with little to indicate for her efforts.

To go that off, Chow may wish to think about co-opting just a few of the higher concepts provided by a few of her opponents within the mayoral race.

Candidate and metropolis councillor Josh Matlow, for instance, provided a devoted “Metropolis Works Fund” — a two per cent property tax levy. The identify echoes Tory’s 1.5 per cent annual “Metropolis Constructing Fund” property tax levy devoted to the capital value of constructing transit and housing.

The rationale for a brand new devoted levy is straightforward: a brand new bus or streetcar isn’t price a lot in case you can’t afford to pay drivers. And new housing means new residents, who will need extra leisure packages, extra library hours and different municipal companies.

A two per cent annual enhance works out to simply $67 additional for the typical family however would elevate huge cash: about $234 million a yr by 2026, in accordance with Matlow’s platform, which was reviewed by former parliamentary finances officer Kevin Web page. That’s sufficient to offset the price of restoring TTC service cuts, growing library hours, bettering snow elimination and hiring extra mental-health response groups, with sufficient left over to fill a bunch extra potholes.

By making a devoted fund to pay for service enhancements, Chow might provide accountability for her tax will increase. I’m imagining indicators posted in locations throughout Toronto: “These prolonged library hours are dropped at you by the Metropolis Works Fund,” “This bus service is dropped at you by the Metropolis Works Fund” and so forth.

Make it crystal clear what companies these elevated taxes are paying for, in order that anybody who opposes them should clarify why these companies must be reduce.

Nonetheless, Chow may also face criticism that elevated taxes will make life much less inexpensive. Chow has rightly identified that the town already affords packages for low-income seniors and folks with disabilities that take the sting out of property tax hikes, however an expanded tax reduction program could possibly be good politics.

Mayoral candidate Mitzie Hunter, in her platform, proposed a plan to rebate 50 per cent of the annual property tax enhance to households incomes lower than $80,000 per yr. It’s an concept price learning, as it will be an actual step towards making Toronto’s property tax system extra progressive.

And right here’s yet one more concept price contemplating. Elevated spending at metropolis corridor gained’t have the influence it ought to if metropolis departments stay dysfunctional. Metropolis corridor’s current CafeTO challenges, for instance, with lengthy delays and patio allow rejections, have been partly the results of three departments getting tasked with the roll-out course of, with nobody actually in cost.

Coverage analyst Chloe Brown, who ran one other robust mayoral marketing campaign after a third-place end in final fall’s election, provided as a part of her platform a wise restructuring of metropolis corridor, changing at the moment’s labyrinth of paperwork with a “robust commissioners” system, during which eight divisional managers would have clear obligations. It’s the sort of structural change metropolis corridor might use to make sure cash is being spent successfully.

By embracing a few of her challengers’ higher concepts, Chow can fill the gaps in her personal platform — which was fairly mild on specifics — and mix items right into a sort of municipal coverage Voltron. As a result of Chow has the liberty to lift income, she’s the primary mayor in a very long time with a possibility to result in actual service enhancements. It gained’t be straightforward — however a minimum of it’s doable.

SHARE: