As Rae Ann Kaylie sat on her mom’s sofa within the wake of her dying, the Judaica felt overwhelming.
Over 50 menorahs adorned the cabinets. A dozen seder plates had been meticulously hung alongside a trove of Jewish artwork on every wall. And numerous dreidels, kiddush cups and shofars stuffed each nook of the 1,100-square-foot dwelling in Rockville, Maryland.
There have been so many hamsas hanging close to the doorway, Kaylie joked, “Whoa, Mother, what on earth? Like, how a lot evil eye do we’ve in right here?”
For 35 years, Kaylie’s mom, Deborah Brodie, had amassed a set of over 200 Jewish ritual objects, which she had used as a hands-on classroom for her Hebrew faculty college students with particular wants. Among the many assortment, Brodie had additionally obtained a Torah from Ebay, which her college students used to follow for his or her b’nai mitzvah.
“She wasn’t the one who was like, ‘Oh, don’t contact it. You’re going to interrupt it,’” Kaylie stated. “She was like, ‘Contact it, right here, take a bunch,’ you recognize what I imply, and that was actually cool about her total assortment.”

Deborah Brodie and Jay Brill spent many years constructing an enormous assortment of Judaica that can now be housed on the Lillian and Albert Small Capital Jewish Museum. (Courtesy Rae Ann Kaylie)
Brodie — often called “Bubbie Cookie” to her household — had not constructed the gathering alone. Her longtime associate, Jay Brill, whom she met by way of a Washington Jewish Week personals advert in 1986, was alongside her all through the journey, touring along with her to all 50 states to promote Jewish jewellery and a computerized Hebrew-learning program they created collectively.
Through the years, the couple attended each B’nai Shalom and Shaare Tefila Congregation, two Conservative synagogues in Olney, Maryland. Towards the tip of their lives, they attended Chabad of Olney, whose rabbi officiated their funerals.
However after Brodie, 76, and Brill, 74, died in February simply 19 days aside, Kaylie stated she and her household had been confronted with a painful query: What would occur to the couple’s lifetime of Jewish devotion of their absence?
“All of us picked one thing we wished, however then, you recognize, you don’t need to promote it, you don’t need to make any cash off of it,” Kaylie stated. “It was simply making an attempt to determine, like, what can we do to additional her ardour, her imaginative and prescient?”
The reply, Kaylie stated, arrived by way of Instagram.
Earlier this month, Kaylie despatched a easy message to Nick Fox, who operates a social media sequence titled “Millenial Inheritance,” writing, “Hey, you need to see a whole lot of menorahs?”
Since October, Fox has documented dozens of inheritance tales throughout his social media channels, that includes individuals grappling with their late dad and mom’ huge collections of Breyer Horse collectible figurines, salt and pepper shakers and Christmas decorations.
However whereas Fox stated the mission of his web page is just not essentially to assist individuals discover properties for inherited collections, Kaylie’s story felt completely different.
As he seen photographs of Brodie and Brill’s dwelling, Fox, who’s Catholic, stated that he instantly flashed again to childhood recollections attending his classmates’ bar mitzvahs and receiving memento hamsas from their journeys to Israel.
“It was the truth that she was actively grieving and actually had no thought what to do, and I believe the truth that I used to be raised how I used to be, the place I used to be, that I had a information of what these items was and what it meant,” Fox stated.
Simply days later, Fox posted a brief video for his 200,000 followers that includes snippets of the sprawling assortment together with a name to assist discover it a everlasting dwelling that will “adore it the best way Rae Ann’s mother did.”
Because the publish garnered a whole bunch of feedback providing concepts for the gathering’s future and tributes to Brodie’s contributions to Jewish schooling, it was additionally making its method by way of Washington’s Jewish group.

Menorahs inside the house of Deborah Brodie and Jay Brill in Rockville, Maryland. (Alex Fradkin)
The morning after the publish, Jonathan Edelman, the collections curator for the Lillian and Albert Small Capital Jewish Museum, stated he woke as much as dozens of messages from individuals urging the museum to discover a dwelling for the gathering.
“It was so significant that so many individuals within the broader group, and who’ve by no means stopped in our museum, tagged us and stated, you recognize, this needs to be the house of this type of wild story and this superb assortment,” Edelman stated.
By the next weekend, Edelman had travelled to Brodie’s dwelling to satisfy with Rae Ann to view the gathering himself. However even after seeing Fox’s publish, Edelman stated he was unprepared for what awaited him inside.
“It was unimaginable, floor-to-ceiling Judaica like I’d by no means seen in anybody’s dwelling earlier than,” Edelman stated. “It wasn’t simply thrown on a shelf. It was so thoughtfully laid out. I imply, she had seder plates and hanukkiot hanging on the wall, which isn’t any simple activity to do…it felt like a museum high quality show. It was actually spectacular.”
Edelman shortly reported again to the museum, which opened in June 2023, telling them that he believed he had stumbled upon an “unimaginable alternative” to launch its inaugural schooling assortment.
Now, the Capital Jewish Museum has plans to accommodate the whole thing of Brodie and Brill’s assortment in its second-floor schooling and program house, the Neighborhood Motion Lab, the place guests will be capable of work together with the Judaica firsthand, simply as Brodie inspired her college students to do in her dwelling.
The museum additionally plans to {photograph} the gathering so it’s accessible on-line, and lend particular person items to colleges and organizations within the space for instructional use.

The Neighborhood Motion Lab within the Lillian and Albert Small Capital Jewish Museum. (Alex Fradkin)
“After I heard her mom’s story, you recognize, we had been doing the identical factor. Our objective was Jewish schooling, and he or she did it as a person, we’re doing it as an establishment,” Edelman stated. “It means a lot for us to honor her mom’s reminiscence by doing the work that she devoted her life to…it feels significantly particular.”
However whereas Fox stated he was not stunned by the outpouring of help and solutions from the Jewish group, he stated different Jews that inherit giant portions of Judaica mustn’t look to Kaylie’s story as a roadmap.
“That is absolute best-case state of affairs, however it additionally makes it so very distinctive, as a result of there aren’t going to be a whole lot of collections that museums often are going to tackle,” Fox stated, including that individuals mustn’t assume that inheritances will discover a place in a museum.
As an alternative, Fox stated he inspired people who inherit Jewish collections to seek the advice of their native Jewish group facilities or synagogues to see if they may have a use for them.
“Within the case of somebody having an incredible quantity of Judaica, I believe one of the simplest ways could be to faucet into your community, first, discuss to people who you recognize which might be in your group,” Fox stated. “After which if it goes nowhere, then you might have each proper to, you recognize, in case you’re seeking to promote it, or in case you’re seeking to donate it, I believe the massive ask could be, what would your kin need performed with that stuff?”

Rae Ann Kaylie and her mom, Deborah Brodie. (Courtesy Rae Ann Kaylie)
Rachel Steinhardt, a California resident who organized a large-scale Judaica drive for individuals impacted by the Palisades and Eaton fires final 12 months, really helpful that individuals who discover themselves with inherited Judaica they can not maintain flip to native Fb teams or Judaica rehoming communities akin to L’dor V’dor Judaica or Heritage Judaica.
“New Judaica is nice, however individuals undoubtedly worth one thing that has been touched and beloved and appreciated over time…you need one thing that has just a little soul in it,” Steinhardt stated. “So I believe that even one thing that’s not of worth, different individuals can recognize that it has been beloved and need to purchase it.”
Reflecting on Fox’s resolution to highlight her mom’s assortment, Kaylie stated that he had been a “guardian angel.”
“He didn’t have to do this, and actually, it’s due to him that we’re in a position to have my mother’s legacy be how we may have wished it,” Kaylie stated.
Edelman stated he expects the gathering to be put in within the museum someday this summer season, the place it will likely be displayed alongside a plaque honoring “Bubbie Cookie” and “Zayde Jay,” names the couple had been referred to by their households.
For Kaylie, imagining the long run museum guests dealing with her mom’s kiddush cups and menorahs felt like “precisely how she would have wished it.”
“Once we misplaced Bubbie Cookie, we stated the legend of Bubbie Cookie was over,” Kaylie stated. “And now, for the legend and the legacy to maneuver on, I imply, it’s unreal. It’s, I’ve no phrases, I can’t even articulate it. It’s simply superb.”
Passover could also be over, however your likelihood to help unbiased Jewish journalism is not. Assist JTA maintain reporting the tales that outline our period.
















