Citizen journalist and COVID-whistleblower Zhang Zhan, who spent 4 years in jail for her in-depth reporting from Wuhan within the early days of the pandemic, was sentenced to a different 4 years in a closed-door trial in Shanghai on September 19. Worldwide diplomats and observers have been denied entry to the trial, and it’s not identified whether or not Zhang had any authorized illustration. Press-freedom and human-rights teams condemned the newest sentence, extensively seen as retaliation for Zhang’s continued outspokenness about China’s human-rights violations towards prisoners, political dissidents, and whistleblowers. An announcement from U.N. Human Rights Workplace spokesperson Jeremy Laurence known as Zhang’s sentencing “on the imprecise and ill-defined cost of ‘selecting quarrels and frightening bother’ […] deeply disturbing. […] We name for her rapid and unconditional launch.”
Zhang’s sentencing comes on the heels of a brand new legislation, scheduled to take impact on November 1, that goals to enhance China’s early-warning and response system for public-health threats “by empowering people and permitting them to report emergencies, bypassing the federal government’s normal hierarchical construction.” Xinhua reported that the legislation would require “medical establishments and on-duty employees to report precise or potential public well being emergencies via the web direct reporting system inside two hours. People or teams also needs to report such circumstances instantly to native authorities or illness management companies, and people whose studies are later discovered to not be a public well being emergency is not going to face authorized legal responsibility.” However given the cruel remedy meted out to journalists corresponding to Zhang Zhan and medical professionals corresponding to Dr. Li Wenliang who tried to alert the general public to the then-emerging coronavirus, it’s unclear whether or not odd residents will likely be keen to threat reporting emergencies to the Chinese language authorities, even underneath the auspices of the brand new legislation. The Chinese language authorities continues to make use of censorship, harassment, and prosecution (on such fees as rumor-mongering and selecting quarrels) to discourage whistle-blowers who’ve tried to name consideration to questions of safety with generic medicines, the usage of unwashed gas tankers to move cooking oil, the mass lead poisoning of a whole bunch of kindergarteners in Gansu Province, and different food- and consumer-product security scandals.
At The Guardian, Amy Hawkins reported on worldwide reactions to Zhang Zhan’s sentencing:
Jeremy Laurence, a spokesperson for the UN human rights workplace, mentioned studies of Zhang’s rearrest and sentencing have been “deeply disturbing”.
He mentioned: “That is the second time Zhang has been convicted and subjected to a custodial sentence for this offence. We name for her rapid and unconditional launch.”
Aleksandra Bielakowska, an advocacy supervisor for RSF [Reporters Without Borders], mentioned Zhang’s sentence was “completely appalling, including that the citizen journalist “must be celebrated globally as an ‘info hero’, not trapped in brutal jail circumstances”.
Zhang is believed to have lived underneath shut surveillance since being launched in Could final 12 months after her first four-year time period in jail. In August 2024, she was detained and later charged with “selecting quarrels and frightening bother”, together with her indictment citing posts on social media that “critically broken the nation’s picture”. The authorities haven’t publicly confirmed what the precise offending social media posts have been. [Source]
A chunk from Reporters With out Borders (RSF) described the secrecy surrounding Zhang’s detention and closed-door trial:
In keeping with RSF sources and unbiased Chinese language human rights teams, together with Weiquanwang, Zhang Zhan was sentenced to 4 years in jail on fabricated fees of “selecting quarrels and frightening bother” on 19 September 2025 following a closed-door trial.
The 2021 RSF Press Freedom Award laureate has been lower off from the skin world for greater than a 12 months, together with her whereabouts and circumstances stored secret. On the day of her trial on the Pudong New Space Individuals’s Court docket in Shanghai, diplomats from at the least seven nations have been denied entry. Not less than 5 activists looking for to look at proceedings have been additionally barred from getting into and, in some circumstances, briefly detained.
On 21 September, each the United Nations’ Workplace of the Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights and the European Fee condemned the sentencing of Zhang Zhan and known as for her rapid and unconditional launch. [Source]
Reuters’ Clare Jim, Jessie Pang, and Branda Goh reported on Zhang’s pandemic reporting, the 4 years she spent in jail (throughout which era she went on a starvation strike to protest ill-treatment), and the current trial and sentencing:
Friday’s sentencing adopted Zhang’s reporting on China’s human rights abuses, RSF mentioned. Her former lawyer Ren posted on X that the brand new fees have been based mostly on Zhang’s touch upon abroad web sites and she or he shouldn’t be deemed responsible.
China’s authorities have by no means publicly specified what actions Zhang was charged for.
“That is the second time Zhang Zhan has confronted trial on baseless fees that quantity to nothing greater than a blatant act of persecution for her journalism work,” mentioned Beh Lih Yi, Asia-Pacific director for the New York-based Committee to Defend Journalists. “Chinese language authorities should put an finish to the arbitrary detention of Zhang, drop all fees, and free her instantly.” [Source]
The Committee to Defend Journalists (CPJ) outlined the circumstances of Zhang’s re-arrest late final summer time, following her continued efforts to convey consideration to China’s suppression of human rights and free speech:
Zhang was arrested in August 2024, not lengthy after launching a YouTube channel the place she reported tales starting from a live-streamed interview with Liu Dongbao, who petitioned officers to analyze his remedy whereas in detention, to documentation of dwelling circumstances in China.
Her arrest got here simply three months after ending a four-year jail sentence for her protection of the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, which included interviews with native enterprise house owners impacted by the pandemic, and with employees who struggled to search out employment within the metropolis.
In Could, CPJ joined 58 different organizations in issuing a joint assertion demanding Zhang’s rapid launch and condemning the Chinese language authorities for her continued arbitrary detention.
China was the world’s worst jailer of journalists with 52 behind bars as of December 1, 2024, in keeping with CPJ’s analysis. [Source]
